Belonging Matters
Written By Anthony I. Butler
When to Pivot: How Leaders Know It’s Time to Change Course or Walk Away
A Companion Resource to the Belonging at the Top Podcast, Season 2, Episode 7
(~7.9-minute read)
Most leaders are trained to push through. Persistence gets celebrated, and quitting gets a bad reputation.
But persistence without progress is not a virtue. It is a slow leak of time, money, energy, and talent. Knowing when to change course, whether that means a project, a role, or an entire organization, is one of the least discussed and most consequential leadership skills.
This article defines what a pivot actually is, explains how to spot the signs on your team and in yourself, and lays out a practical framework for making the call strategically instead of emotionally.
What We Mean by a Pivot
A pivot is a deliberate change of direction because what you are doing now is not working. It shows up in a few different forms.
Pivoting a project or idea. Changing a product, a campaign, a program, or a business model, or walking away from it entirely.
Pivoting your track. Staying with the organization but moving to a different path because the one you were on no longer fits.
Pivoting out of the organization. Leaving for a new employer, a new field, or your own venture.
One boundary matters here. This article is about chosen pivots, the ones you make on your own terms. It does not cover forced exits such as a performance improvement plan, which is usually the last step before someone is asked to leave, or sudden life events that change your plans overnight.
The Core Signal: Struggling Without Progress
The simplest test is this: are you putting in real effort and still not moving forward? Lots of research, lots of hard work, and little to show for it, not even the unintended side benefits that sometimes keep a flawed project worth running.
If your reports sound the same for weeks, if the goals are not being met, and if the work is no longer fulfilling, you are probably spinning your wheels. That is the moment to ask what a pivot would look like.
Spot the Quiet Exit on Your Team
Human resources has a term for the resignation that arrives without warning: a regretted loss. A strong employee slides a notice across the desk, and the leader is stunned. By that point, the employee has usually spent weeks or months deciding. The decision process was invisible only because no one was looking.
Research on turnover supports this. Employees typically move through a stretch of dissatisfaction, thinking about leaving, and searching before they actually quit (Mobley, 1977). That gap is your window to notice and respond.
Watch your highest performers closely. They tend to check out slowly. A superstar becomes merely very good, which is still above the team average, so nobody worries. Silent checkouts hide in plain sight because output stays respectable. Decide in advance how you will know when a top performer has taken a step back, even though the numbers still look fine.
Watch progress and ideas. Three signals worth tracking:
Progress slows, and status updates start to look the same from one report to the next.
People begin to float alternatives: "Should we try this other thing instead?"
People stop offering suggestions altogether. If they do not feel safe disagreeing, silence is the signal.
That last point is why psychological safety matters so much. Edmondson (1999) defines it as a shared belief that a team is safe for interpersonal risk taking. Without it, your team will not tell you the project is off track or that they are thinking about leaving, and you will not see the cues at all.
Watch workload and burnout. A high-performing team that meets every deadline and keeps every stakeholder happy may be paying for it at night and on weekends. Burnout, which Maslach and Leiter (2016) describe as a combination of exhaustion, cynicism, and a reduced sense of accomplishment, is a leading reason good people start asking whether it is worth it. Look past "we all get along" and understand what the actual work demands.
Leave and vacation policies exist for a reason. If you believe a project cannot finish without a particular person, pause the project, reallocate resources, and let that person rest. Then take your own advice. Leaders are often the ones who answer messages at six in the morning while everyone else is on vacation.
Why Your Own Pivot Is Harder
Noticing that someone else needs to change course is one thing. Deciding that you do is far harder, especially when the project is yours: your idea, your program, your handbook, your company.
Ownership makes it personal. Time, money, and energy have gone in, so the thought is, "I have invested too much to quit now." Researchers call this the sunk cost effect (Arkes & Blumer, 1985), and it is closely related to escalation of commitment, the tendency to keep investing in a failing course of action to justify earlier decisions (Staw, 1976). Sometimes the responsible choice is to measure your losses and stop the bleeding.
Three safeguards help.
Use objective measures. "It feels like it will turn around in six months" and "if only we land this one client" are hopes, not measures. Define clear return on investment targets, check them on a schedule, and ask how likely your assumptions really are within the time you have.
Build in dissent, and then listen to it. You need people who will say, "This is not working, and you should move on." You also need to take them seriously. A leader who hears the whole team say no and proceeds anyway is either too emotional about the idea or does not trust the team. Both are warning signs.
Redefine bias for action. Acting on the data does not always mean doing more. Sometimes the decisive step is the decision to stop. Making the call is the action. Executing it well, without harming the team or the rest of the organization, is the second part.
It is also worth knowing your own pattern. If you tend to hold on too long, whether to projects, relationships that no longer serve you, or the clothes in your closet from college, that habit probably shows up at work too. By the middle of a career, most people know whether they are a hanger-on. Many will recognize the thought, "I should have done that two years ago."
Strengths, Preferences, and the Passion Trap
There is a difference between what you are good at and what you enjoy. You can be skilled at work you do not like and keep getting more of it because you are good. Eventually, the right move may be to hand that work to someone who values it and move toward something better aligned.
Passion alone is also a shaky foundation. Passion comes in waves. Turning it into a job can strip out the energy that made it exciting, because every job contains plenty of unglamorous work. Newport (2012) argues that people build satisfying careers by developing rare and valuable skills first, and that passion tends to follow mastery. Start from what you are good at, then test whether it can earn the income you need.
Leaders face a related trap. Promotions often reward what you did well in the previous role, and then the new role asks for things you are not good at and may never be. Nobody is good at everything. Humility means recognizing when you are in a seat that does not fit, and being willing to adjust before the decision is made for you.
When the Pivot Means Leaving the Organization
The framework is the same, and the stakes are higher. Reasons to leave are not always dramatic. Sometimes you hit a ceiling: the role is great, but there is nowhere left to grow. Sometimes you are not being challenged, and boredom is quietly lowering your standards. Sometimes the culture simply is not right for you. Hirschman (1970) described the basic options as exit, voice, and loyalty. Before you exit, it is worth asking whether voice, a direct conversation about a new track or new challenge, could solve the problem.
Keep the decision objective. Do not resign because someone upset you one afternoon or because you were passed over for a promotion you assumed was yours. Ask the hard questions. Were you actually qualified? Was the other candidate stronger? Define targets for what you need, and test the situation against them.
Deciding that you should leave is usually the easier part. Doing it well is harder, especially in a tight job market. Engagement data from Gallup show that only about a third of employees are engaged at work, so many people are unhappy and looking, while openings are scarce. The talent is there. The jobs are not always.
That reality is why a plan matters. Resigning in anger is occasionally necessary for health and safety. It is rarely wise for someone with a family, a mortgage, or people who depend on them. Do not abandon ship without a life jacket.
Treat the plan as the first step of the pivot itself. Decide what comes next. Put out feelers, speak with a recruiter, build a side venture that replaces the income, or line up the next role. Then choose your timing so that your lifestyle and your obligations are protected.
One more honest point. Pivoting is easier near the start of a career than at the top. There are more entry-level openings than C-suite roles, and more to weigh at senior levels. That is a feature of the market, not a judgment about any role, but senior leaders should plan for a longer runway.
Practical Actions for Monday Morning
Check on your top performers. Have a real one-on-one conversation with each of them this week, and ask what would make their work more challenging and fulfilling.
Audit workload. Look at who is working late, who works weekends, and who has not taken time off. Give people permission to rest, and pause work if needed.
Listen for silence. Notice who stopped offering ideas or pushing back, and ask what would make it safer to speak up.
Set objective measures for your own projects. Write down the return on investment targets and a date to review them honestly.
Appoint your honest voices. Identify two or three people who will tell you the truth, and commit to listening to them.
Separate strengths from preferences. List what you are good at, what you enjoy, and where those overlap. Notice where you are working in a gap.
Build the plan before the exit. If you are considering leaving, write down your financial runway, your next steps, and the conversation you want to have first.
Continue the Conversation
This edition of Belonging Matters is a companion to Season 2, Episode 7 of the Belonging at the Top podcast. Listen to the full episode for deeper discussion, real-world examples, and additional context on knowing when to pivot.
References
Arkes, H. R., & Blumer, C. (1985). The psychology of sunk cost. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 35(1), 124-140.
Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350-383.
Gallup. (n.d.). U.S. employee engagement. Gallup, Inc.
Hirschman, A. O. (1970). Exit, voice, and loyalty: Responses to decline in firms, organizations, and states. Harvard University Press.
Maslach, C., & Leiter, M. P. (2016). Understanding the burnout experience: Recent research and its implications for psychiatry. World Psychiatry, 15(2), 103-111.
Mobley, W. H. (1977). Intermediate linkages in the relationship between job satisfaction and employee turnover. Journal of Applied Psychology, 62(2), 237-240.
Newport, C. (2012). So good they can't ignore you: Why skills trump passion in the quest for work you love. Grand Central Publishing.
Staw, B. M. (1976). Knee-deep in the big muddy: A study of escalating commitment to a chosen course of action. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 16(1), 27-44.

